The Court of Appeal handed down its much-anticipated judgment on the Dentons v Solicitors Regulation Authority case on 27/4/26, allowing the profession to breathe another sigh of relief (hot on the heels of the Mazur judgment).

Why has the profession been holding its breath?

At its most basic level, the case was about whether a breach of the Money Laundering Regulations (MLRs) (or any other legal or regulatory obligation), no matter how serious, automatically amounts to a breach of the SRA standards and regulations and therefore amounts to a professional misconduct issue.  Dentons and the Solicitors Disciplinary Tribunal (SDT)’s position was that it did not. The SRA and the High Court’s position was that it did. The Court of Appeal has sided with Dentons and the SDT (on this point at least) concluding that there must be an element of seriousness before such a breach will amount to misconduct.  In other words, breaching a legal or regulatory obligation will not amount to a strict liability conduct offence.

What was the case about?

  • The SRA prosecuted the law firm Dentons for breaching its obligations under the MLR 2007 between 2013 and 2017 and therefore breaching the SRA Principles and outcomes to comply with legal and regulatory obligations.
  • In 2024 the SDT accepted there had been a breach of the MLR 2007, particularly in relation to taking adequate measures to establish source of wealth and funds in relation to a high-risk non-domestic politically exposed person (PEP) client. However, the SDT concluded that they were inadvertent breaches and not serious enough to warrant misconduct findings. The case was dismissed.
  • The SRA appealed that decision.
  • The High Court (in its judgment dated 11/3/25) quashed the SDT’s decision, found that the MLR 2007 breaches amounted to strict liability offences and that severity was not required to prove misconduct, and therefore sent the case back to the SDT for rehearing. Dentons were also ordered to pay the SRA’s costs of the original hearing and the appeal.
  • Dentons appealed on various grounds to the Court of Appeal (CA).

Equivalent SRA standards & regulations in a post 2019-world

Although the case was brought under the old SRA Principles, Code of conduct and Outcomes from pre-2019, to understand it in today’s context, we are looking at paragraph 7.1 of the Code of Conduct for Solicitors (you keep up to date with and follow the law and regulation governing the way you work) and paragraph 2.1(a) of the Code of Conduct for Firms (you comply with all the SRA’s regulatory arrangements, as well as with other regulatory and legislative requirements, which apply to you).  In terms of the SRA Principles 2019, the most relevant principles are 1 and 2 (upholding the rule of law and public trust & confidence in the solicitors’ profession).

Court of Appeal decision

The CA has concluded that the High Court was wrong to find that any breach of the MLRs would effectively amount to a strict liability breach of the SRA Principles or Codes of Conduct.  The test as to whether a solicitor’s conduct amounts to such a breach is now one of “sufficient seriousness”, with the CA saying, “We consider that on any case brought before the SDT the question for it is whether the conduct in question would be considered sufficiently serious by competent and reputable solicitors that it be categorised as professional misconduct”.

Their reasoning was as follows:

  • The Common law position on pursuing solicitors for professional misconduct is that “mere negligence was not enough; there had to be an element of seriousness calling for professional censure”;
  • Section 28(3) Legal Services Act 2007 requires regulators to only pursue misconduct cases where action is needed taking a “transparent, accountable, proportionate, consistent and targeted” approach;
  • The SRA’s own rules on issuing SDT proceedings and their Enforcement Strategy impose threshold conditions of seriousness before investigating an alleged breach.

What this means for the profession

This is a relief for the profession and appears to be the common-sense approach to take.  A strict liability approach to any breaches, particularly where findings of misconduct can lead to all sorts of other negative consequences, sends a wave of terror over most people! The CA’s approach means that the SRA and the SDT will not be able to/ be required to pursue, for professional misconduct, every solicitor or firm that fails (for example) to complete a client and matter risk assessment (CMRA) on every single matter the MLRs require them to (i.e. all in-scope clients and matters). The example the CA gave was that if the High Court’s strict liability approach was followed, a firm which owned its office building and didn’t have appropriate firefighting equipment in place, putting them in breach of Health & Safety regulations, would be taken to the SDT and found to have breached the SRA Codes of Conduct and be sanctioned accordingly, with the SDT unable to refuse to hear an allegation on the grounds that is was not sufficiently serious to occupy their time.

This is not to say that firms and solicitors should be breaching their legal and regulatory obligations and not worrying about completing CMRAs or carrying out sufficient source of funds enquiries (or throwing out their fire extinguishers!).  Indeed, the CA upheld the High Court’s decision to send the case against Dentons back to the SDT to reconsider the claims brought against it by the SRA, namely whether the AML breaches were sufficiently serious to amount to misconduct.

What this means for Dentons

The original SDT concluded that in this specific case, the failure to ask sufficient questions about source of funds and wealth of a high-risk PEP was an “inadvertent breach” and therefore not sufficiently serious to impose a sanction.  This conclusion appeared to have been reinforced by the weight the SDT apparently placed on the fact that the PEP-client in question had been inherited by Dentons following a merger with another firm and the Dentons’ partners had relied on the original client-partner to have carried out the necessary AML checks.

The CA said they had “difficulty in understanding” how the SDT had been able to conclude that a failure of this sort, not just at the outset, but throughout the retainer (whether or not partners had relied on someone else having done so) could be characterised as being “entirely inadvertent“, hence they have remitted the case to the SDT to reconsider this point applying the “sufficiently serious” test.

Whilst not wishing to pre-judge the SDT’s decision, it does seem quite a serious omission by Dentons (based on what we know), albeit one of their original arguments was that they should not be judged by today’s AML standards for something that happened 9-13 years ago.

Action points

  1. Understand the requirements of the MLRs and ensure your policies and procedures are up to date and being followed by staff.
  2. Be alive to the possibility of your client being a PEP, even if you try to avoid acting for them because they are outside your risk appetite (and be aware of the FCA PEP guidance, which applies to law firms already, which firmly warns against applying a generic approach to all PEPs). All firms should be screening for PEPs (and sanctions) not only at the outset of the retainer but on an on-going monitoring basis (PEP and sanctions status can change throughout the lifetime of the retainer).
  3. Ensure your source of funds and wealth enquiries are thorough (albeit taking a risk-based approach – the higher the risk, such as a PEP from a high-risk non-EEA country (as was the case in the Dentons’ scenario), the more scrutiny will be required.
  4. If you merge with, or take over another firm, ensure you check the AML compliance standards of the other firm carefully – do not assume their standards are your standards.
  5. This decision may slightly lessen the double-jeopardy concern in relation to the FCA takeover of AML regulation in due course – the big concern was that if all AML breaches were automatically deemed to be SRA conduct breaches, dual investigations/ enforcement action would be almost inevitable in all cases.
  6. Take your legal and regulatory obligations seriously. Don’t rely on being able to argue insufficient seriousness if accused of a breach. Not everyone has the deep pockets of Dentons!
  7. Have another look at the SRA Principles and Codes of Conduct and familiarise yourself with SRA expectations. This is particularly important in light of the increased focus on professional ethics and continuing competence (see our recent article on this subject here).
  8. Look out for updated SRA guidance on the “sufficiently serious” point. What amounts to being “considered sufficiently serious by competent and reputable solicitors” is likely to generate debate.  As others have already commented, firms and COLPs should be wary, following the CA’s judgment, of conflating the SRA/ SDT’s requirement to assess seriousness in misconduct cases with their own reporting obligations.  Paragraph 3.10 of the Code of Conduct for Firms requires prompt reporting of matters that firms reasonably believe should be drawn to the SRA’s attention so that they can judge seriousness (distinct from the obligation under paragraph 3.9 to report serious breaches). The Court of Appeal was concerned with the SRA and SDT’s decision-making powers, not firms’ or COLPs’ reporting duties.

Do reach out if we can be of any assistance with the above action points.